Review of MAE NAAK
From “Opera” Magazine
January 2006
The Bangkok Opera, which opened its first full season in September 2004, is the kind of company one would usually call a mom-and-pop operation, except in this case there’s only a pop. Formed in 2001 by the Thai-born composer and author Somtow Sucharitkul, who has spent a lifetime reconciling his Asian heritage and his Eton-Cambridge education, the company was born of the same cultural tension that has fuelled its founder’s art. Somtow, who extended the sonorities and techniques of traditional Thai instruments as a Boulez acolyte in the 1970s, turned to writing genre fiction in the 1980s, when his westernized fantasist’s eye gradually rediscovered Thailand’s rich folklore. With his latest musical incarnation in the 1990s as a neo-Romantic, those two creative sides have now fused together on the operatic stage.
Mae Naak, Somtow’s second opera based on a Thai theme, was billed in the local English-language press as “Thailand’s most famous ghost story”, though the result on stage was rather more complicated. In brief, the plot concerns a solder going off to war just as he finds out his wife is pregnant; years later, reunited with her, he eventually discovers she is now a ghost haunting others in the village. Out of civic responsibility, he rejects her in this life, hoping to reunite in the next.
While Somtow’s libretto bends this traditional tale to modern sensibilities, using flashbacks and other cinematic conventions, his music comes squarely from the opposite direction, stretching a post-Wagnerian Germanic language eastward. The composer’s unassuming description in the programme note – essentially, “Thai folk music meets the Hollywood horror movie soundtrack –” was fine for Bangkok’s bndding audiences, though more experienced opera listeners could follow a few shrewd brushstrokes of Berg and Bartók.
This production, largely reconceived and recast from the piece’s premiere in 2003, revolved smoothly around the director Henry Akina’s efficiently other-worldly atmosphere. The cast mixed a handful of promising local singers (including soprano Catherine Sam Harsono and tenor Francis Chan) with some solid young international performers (notably the sopranos Ronit Widmann-Levy, Saundra DeAthos, and Grace Echauri). As the soldier Maak, the Korean baritone Kyu Won Han made a particularly heroic showing.
Little in either the cast or production, however, detracted from the presence of Nancy Yuen, the Hong Kong-born, London-based soprano for whom the title role was written. Though she could deftly negotiate spans of more than an octave in a single phrase, Yuen was often more effective on a single pitch, investing each moment with a range of timbre that communicated on the surface an exquisite emotional depth.
— KEN SMITH
Ken Smith - Opera Magazine, London Jan 2006 (Jan 4, 2006)
MCLEAN ORCHESTRA TACKLES SUCHARITKUL'S UNIVERSE
by Claudia Moore
Somtow Sucharitkul is one of the most astonishing, controversial, and colorful artists to come to the United States out of Southeast Asia. He is an avant-garde composer whose most recent major work, Gongula 3, was premiered at Bangkok's Asian Composer's Expo '78 and was called "brilliant" and "stunning" by International Newsweekly Asia Week. A month before the premiere, however, the orchestra went on strike ...
"My piece used traditional Thai instruments and Western instruments in new combinations, new sonorities," Sucharitkul said. "The orchestra decided that I had polluted the Sacredness of the ancient instruments. It took a lot of persuasion to get them to play it... but this didn't seem to bother the critics." The day before the the concert, however, which was at Thailand's National Theater, someone had hidden the piano, and Sucharitkul had to have a new one moved in.
Somtow Sucharitkul is only 27 years old, but his music has been performed in England, Germany, Holland, Japan, Australia, Hong Kong, and other countries, and has been televised and broadcast on four continents. Japan's prestigious NHK TV made a documentary about him as he toured Southeast Asia and showed it on prime time. UNESCO has designated him its official Asian music expert, and he was only 19 when he conducted his first orchestra on Dutch National TV. His works include A CATCH OF WATERS for six chamber orchestras surrounding the audience, GONGULA 3 for Thai and Western Instruments, and a new piano piece, LIGHT ON THE SOUND, in which the pianist is required to sing into the piano as well as perform astounding tricks of virtuosity. This last piece will be premiered later this year in four cities by pianist Violet Lam: in Hong Kong, Milan, Rome and Cologne.
The "Sucharitkul Sound", critics say, is a new one, different from the harshness of much modern music. He divides his orchestras into small groups and piles layer after layer on top of each other, tinkling, ringing, energetic sonorities. Often he breaks completely away from the severe restrictions of modern music, introducing almost classical melodic lines that hover plaintively over the atonal textures... sometimes he'll slip into a baroque pavane or a passage of tinkling Southeast Asian music, as though thumbing his nose at the strict seriousness of academic music. "My favorite trick", he says, "is to have it look very stark on paper and then to have it sound very rich ravishing and exotic." Pianist Violet Lam said of his recent piece: "When I saw the score I knew I was going to have to perform acrobatics at the piano. I knew it would be very, very difficult. But only when I started to play did I discover that it was also very, very beautiful."
The McLean Chamber Orchestra, winner of last year's ASCAP Award for adventurous programming, is premiering Somtow Sucharitkul's brand new work, STAR MAKER: IN AN ANTHOLOGY OF UNIVERSES, on June 7th. Even for an orchestra whose dynamic conductor, Dingwall Fleary, has established a name for himself in bringing new works to the concert platform, this work should be quite a challenge. "I admire Dingwall very much," Sucharitkul says. "He didn't flinch at all when I asked him for four toy pianos..."
STAR MAKER is a piece that just grew and grew, Sucharitkul told us. Its five movements are musical depictions of five different theories of the universe, different cosmologies from Plato to Einstein. It's a big piece, despite its brevity. "The first movement is a musical depiction of the theory of the Big Bang... it's obviously a very noisy movement. It goes further, though --- it describes an oscillating universe in which everything finally returns to its source. I did this by making not only the movement, but also every individual musical part a palindrome. It's the most mathematically exact movement, the most academically correct. The platonic universe of the second movement has the strings continually straining for Ideal Beauty, which is represented by a G major chord that is continuously sustained throughout the movement. It also has a part for a shakuhachi or Japanese flute. The third movement---with the toy pianos---is the Mechanistic Universe, which to me is an image of God as a cosmic kid playing with a cosmic Lego set. The fourth---Cosmic Dance---is a pavane. The last movement, Inferno-Purgatorio-Paradiso, is sort of a Reader's Digest condensed version of Dante's Divine Comedy. During the piece, a children's chorus screams, whispers, mutters and moans---but never sings.
"Just as the opening is very, very atonal, so the ending of STAR MAKER is very, very C major indeed..."
When we asked him why, he responded, "Why not? I don't see why I shouldn't do this. In composing school in Europe, the ultimate sin is to have a major chord, or even an octave. But this refinement of post-serialism is the result of centuries of development in the European-American mainstream. I didn't come from that mainstream, and I have to write from my own cultural ambiguity, to forge my own musical language out to the ransackings of whatever musical cultures I encounter."
Sucharitkul writes science fiction in his spare time. He started doing this because one day he found he had a writing block while trying to compose. But within a few months he had taken the publishing scene by storm, too, selling 15 short stories and a novel in the first eighteen months of his second career. His first novel is coming out from Pocket/Simon and Schuster later this year, and he is a frequent cover name in magazines such as Isaac Asimov's SF Magazine. He was a little shy in talking about his sudden appearance in this totally unrelated field, but we got him to admit that he had been nominated for a number of awards in the science fiction field and that the Philadelphia Inquirer, talking about his science fiction, praised him for his "wild imagination and colorful command of language" and called one of his stories "gasp-provoking"!
A strange, manysided artist. Five years ago the Bangkok Post described him as "the most accomplished example of an extremely rare breed...an unusually original composer." But last year a Ford Foundation representative said, much more simply, "He is a genius."
Claudia Moore - Washington Times (26 yrs ago) (Dec 29, 2006)
A triumph rises from a tragedy
Published on Jan 3, 2002
The September 11 attacks have led to two unique concerts in Bangkok. Both involve a Thai artiste who's lived the best part of his life in America - SP Somtow. As a composer and writer, he is something of a Renaissance figure, and who recently spent time in the monkhood.
Soon after he left the monastery, Somtow extend his stay in Thailand as a result of the terrorist attacks. Then an offer to be Musician-in Residence at Mahidol Varsity came up. Having produced Madana the country's first opera, Somtow now focused on two "Peace" concerts in Bangkok.
The first, Dialogues, was commissioned by the Royal Norwegian Embassy on the occasion of the 100th Anniversary of the Nobel Peace Prize. It was a unique concert in many ways as it combined music, poetry, literature and drama in a manner not seen before in the city.
The first half of the concert belonged to two dynamic Norwegian musicians: Ingrid Roynesdal on piano, and Oysetin Sonstad on cello, who used the texts and rhythms of various Norwegian poets and musicians to create a unique 'dialogue' combining textual drama with rhythmic melodies. They had worked more than a year to create this complicated piece that combined many dissolute elements to finally end in harmony.
That set the tone for the second half of the programme, "Songs before Dawn" composed by Somtow in just one month. He chose various Noble Laureate poets but admitted that they were not easy to set to music. However, it gave him a chance to indulge in his passion for mixing and merging different musical idioms and styles.
"This East-West amalgam of rhythms is what I attempted to do two decades back when I was in Thailand, but it was frowned upon and I was driven to America," laughed Somtow. "Today it's accepted everywhere and I'm part of the establishment."
Thus "Songs before Dawn" was a blend of European and Asian songs and instruments. A Japanese pianist, a Chinese harpist, Austrian violinists, a Flemish violin conductor, plus American and Thai singers. There was also the Indian tanpura, Thai 'ching' cymbals and 'mong' gongs in addition to the standard Western orchestral instruments.
As for the poetry, Somtow started and ended with his favourite Japanese Haiku. In between, was an agonising Hungarian poem on the crucifixion where he mixed the sounds of piano, gong, and kettle drums, "to give the effect of a nail being driven in."
The moving poem on Vietnam, by Polish Nobel Laureate Wislawa Szymborska, was interpreted with an intermix of loud baritone and soft soprano voices, accompanied by the violin notes of the children's choir to enact the tragedy of disrupted families during war.
Nobel Laureate Neruda's violent "Stones in the Sky" was a furious flurry of Spanish and Asian rhythms. But it was Hopkins' complex "Windhover" that Somtow admitted was the hardest to set to music. The alliterative words were very close to prose and he chose to "translate" it simply using the crystal clear voice of the soprano.
It was with the same clarity he set Rimbaud's famous "War" poem; a stark sonata where the poet asks: "I dreamed of a war of bright and of might, of unlooked-for magic."
"It is as simple as a musical phrase," said Somtow.
Is it so simple? Somtow certainly made it look easy when he interpreted Ibsen's famous poem "Swan" as an exquisite piano solo; the Chinese "Lullaby" with the succinct flavour of a Chinese opera, and the Thai poem "O Land" with the lush notes of a Germanic romance .
The climactic Bengali poem "Freedom" by Indian Noble Laureate Rabindranath Tagore, was Somtow's favourite, although difficult to translate into the English language and the musical idiom. He used the Indian tanpura with the children's violin choir as a second resonance tone, and had the poem sung in four Indian ragas with Balinese orchestral rhythms. Somtow described it as the ultimate tribute to peace and freedom and confessed that it was the first poem that came to his head when he was asked to create the "Peace" composition.
Norwegian Ambassador Ragne Birte Lund said, "It was a very unique piece, like brightly coloured mosaic stones." HM Princess Galayani thought it was "very unusual."
In the meantime, Somtow has another full-length concert coming up shortly entitled Requiem, created especially for the victims of the Sep 11 tragedy.
The concert has been commissioned by the Thai government and will be held at the World Trade Centre on January 11. "It is another mosaic of multi-cultural rhythms that I've put together with 80 musicians from different countries," said Somtow.
But the musician confessed: "When you write music you're contemplative and in a world of your own. But the final music is social and is a joint act of creation."
That's what Requiem is about - the personal interpretation of public grief. Somtow has as many connections both here and in the US making the composition more personal and complicated. That's why he agreed to do the concert, although he had only six weeks to compose the music.
Again, he has turned to poetry for inspiration, choosing three important American poets to explain the angst of the American tragedy. T S Eliot whose "Wasteland" and '"Four Quartets" are agonising, yet cathartic. Emily Dickinson's "Ashore At Last" and Walt Whitman's "Reconciliation" which augur peace and positivity.
As with "Songs Before Dawn" Somtow chose a varied range of poetical and musical idioms, moods, styles and rhythms to portray a theme which had repercussions around the world, much of it "spiritual".
Somtow confessed that even during his monkhood his "visions" were musical. Indeed, in many ways the Sept 11 incident has proved pivotal in Somtow's life. It prevented him from returning to the US, which led to the re-discovery of his homeland.
The composer has used many young musicians from Mahidol Varsity for the upcoming concert and is amazed by their talent. "They're little fledglings who need to be pushed out of the nest. All they need are the right opportunities and breaks."
Thus, Requiem will not just be a hymn to the past but a triumphant song for the future that Somtow hopes will add an extra dimension to the musical scenario in the country.
Lekha Shankar
Lekha Shankar - THE NATION on Somtow and 9/11 (Jan 3, 2003)